Old Spice: why The Man Your Man Could Smell Like worked

Old Spice sold men's body wash by talking to women, then filmed 186 replies in two and a half days. What worked, what the coupon did and what to borrow.

The most famous advertisement ever made for a men's body wash opens with two words addressed to somebody else: "Hello, ladies."

What follows takes thirty seconds and one unbroken shot. A man in a towel stands in a bathroom and suggests, calmly, that the viewer compare him with her own man. The bathroom lifts away and he is on a boat. Then, without a cut, he is on a horse, and he remarks on it as if it had simply happened to him.

The film went online on 4 February 2010, three days before the Super Bowl. Within months Old Spice, a brand many Americans associated with their grandfathers, was being described by its owner as the number one body wash for men, and its agency had filmed 186 personal replies to people on the internet in two and a half days. This chapter is about what did the work, which was less the horse than it appears.

The short answer

The Man Your Man Could Smell Like was a 2010 campaign for Old Spice body wash, made by the agency Wieden+Kennedy and starring Isaiah Mustafa. It worked because it spoke to women, who by the agency's figures made 60% of body wash purchases, in a joke that men enjoyed as well, and because it was shown where couples would be watching together. A follow-up that July answered people on social media with 186 personal videos in two and a half days. Sales of the body wash rose sharply, although a coupon promotion was running at the same time, and one set of figures showed the brand mainly recovering ground it had lost.

A brand from the grandfather's shelf

Old Spice dates from the 1930s and has belonged to Procter & Gamble since 1990. It was an aftershave and a deodorant long before it was a body wash. By the end of the 2000s the body wash shelf was crowded, and the brand's great asset, its age, was also its problem.

In 2006 the account moved to Wieden+Kennedy, the Portland agency that wrote Just Do It for Nike. We told that story in an earlier chapter. Early in 2010 there was a deadline. Unilever was about to launch Dove Men+Care with a commercial in the Super Bowl, and Dove was a name that a great many women already bought and trusted.

The first two words are the strategy

The agency's own summary of the brief rests on one number: women made 60% of body wash purchases. The person who used the product and the person who picked it off the shelf were, more often than not, two different people. Men's grooming advertising had spent years talking to the first one.

So the film talks to the second, in its opening words, and keeps talking to her. Everything he says is said to her. The man of the title is hers. The product is offered as a way of improving him slightly. Men were never the target and were always in the room, which is why the joke had to be one they would enjoy overhearing.

The media plan followed the same thought. The film went online over the Super Bowl weekend and onto television from the day after the game, in the breaks of American Idol, Lost and the Winter Olympics, which are the kind of programmes couples watch together. Dove had the slot in the game. Old Spice turned up on the same sofas the next day.

A joke for both halves of the sofa

Advertising for men's grooming at the time came in two flavours. One promised that the product would make women pursue you. The other was earnest about being a modern man. The Old Spice film made fun of the whole business of telling men what to be. Its hero is impossible on purpose. He has the tickets, the diamonds, the boat and the horse, and he knows it is ridiculous.

That gave each half of the couple something. She is being flirted with by a man who is in on the joke. He is being teased by someone who is plainly no rival. Nobody is told they are inadequate, which was unusual in a category built largely on telling people exactly that.

The making of it mattered too. Tom Kuntz directed it as a single take, with the set changing around Isaiah Mustafa, a former American football player, over three days of shooting. People watched it again to work out how it had been done. It won the Film Grand Prix at Cannes that June and an Emmy later in the year.

Then it answered back

The second act is the reason the campaign is in textbooks. In the middle of July 2010 the same man, in the same towel and the same bathroom, began replying to people. Someone would post a comment or a question on Twitter, Facebook or Reddit, and a short film addressed to them by name would appear on YouTube soon afterwards. Some went to celebrities with large followings. Many went to nobody in particular.

Wieden+Kennedy made 186 of them in two and a half days, with one actor and one set. By the count in the campaign's awards entry they were watched more than 40 million times in a week. People following along could see a brand read the internet and answer it almost as it happened, which in 2010 was new to most of them.

It is worth being exact about what was new. The films themselves were quick and cheap. The novelty was the arrangement around them. Nobody can pass 186 scripts through a committee in sixty hours, so somebody had agreed beforehand that they would not have to. Our chapter on Amul describes the same bargain between an agency and its client, struck in the 1960s. Speed in marketing is nearly always a question of permission that gets mistaken for a question of talent.

What the audience received was attention. A reply by name from a famous character is a small thing, and people keep small things. They also show them to other people. Everyone who received a film had a reason to post it, so each reply arrived with an audience of its own. Most large brands at the time still treated comments as a matter for the customer service desk. Old Spice treated them as the script.

What it sold, and what the coupon sold

Now the numbers, which are usually quoted without their footnotes.

Wieden+Kennedy says the goal was a 15% rise in body wash sales. By its account, sales of Old Spice Red Zone body wash were up 60% on the previous year by May 2010 and had doubled by July. The figure everybody remembers came from Nielsen and was reported that July: sales up 107% in the latest month. The awards entry offers a third, unit sales up 125% by the end of July. Three measures over three periods have travelled under one headline ever since.

Two things belong beside them. A coupon promotion for the body wash was running in the same weeks, as Techdirt pointed out at the time, so the films cannot take all the credit. And Jack Neff of Advertising Age, using another research firm's figures, found that over the year to the middle of June Old Spice body wash had been roughly flat while the category grew by 8.6%. On that reading the campaign had won back share lost earlier in the year, with couponing doing part of the work. P&G preferred the Nielsen numbers and said the brand had strengthened its position month after month.

To our minds the footnotes improve the story. The film made an old brand worth trying again, and the coupon gave people a reason to try it this week. Our piece on performance marketing and social media marketing calls these two halves of one system. A coupon for a brand nobody is curious about gets ignored, and curiosity without a nudge fades by the weekend. The lesson most often drawn, that a funny video doubled sales unaided, is the one the evidence does not support.

India, 2013: the transplant

The idea came to India in October 2013, for the launch of Old Spice deodorant. Wieden+Kennedy cast Milind Soman as the Indian version of the Man and called the campaign Smell Mantastic. The first film put him on a throne in a towel, delivering a monologue on what makes a man. Regional versions followed, with Soman as men of the North, East, South and West, and a Twitter activity called #MrMantasticSays sent personalised replies to people who commented.

It was well made and widely watched, with 7 lakh views in its first two days. But the afaqs! review quoted a strategist who could not tell whether it was meant for stylish men, for men who disliked them or for their partners: "I don't know whom the brand wants to target." When a second film arrived in April 2014, with Soman in a bathtub and this time addressing women, exchange4media's verdict was that it had failed to create the same buzz.

Our reading is that the visible parts made the trip and the reasons stayed at home. The American film existed because of a particular fact about who bought body wash in American supermarkets, a particular competitor and a particular week. Take those away and what remains is a handsome man being absurd, which is a style, and styles date quickly.

It is the same lesson India's version of Share a Coke teaches from the other side. There the local team kept the reason and changed everything visible. Here the visible things were kept, down to the personalised replies, while the question of who was being spoken to changed from one film to the next.

What stayed

The character outlived the campaign. Mustafa returned in 2015 in a series with the actor Terry Crews, and as recently as 2025 he played the part again in another company's Super Bowl commercial. Fifteen years on, a man in a towel addressing the camera is still understood as a reference to one brand, which is more than most advertising budgets buy.

The idea underneath has lasted better still. Ask who buys, speak to that person, and let the user listen in. It reads like common sense, and most categories still ignore it.

What a smaller brand can take

  1. Find out who buys. The user and the buyer are often different people: the parent who pays the school fee, the daughter who books her father's health check, the owner who chooses for the dog. Pet food is the purest case, since the user cannot read. Write for the person holding the card.
  2. Let the user overhear. The best line in an ad aimed at the buyer is one the user enjoys as well.
  3. Laugh at your category's habits. Old Spice made fun of the way men's products were sold. Most categories have a way of talking that customers are tired of.
  4. Go where both of them are. If two people make the decision, find the screen they share.
  5. Reply on camera. This is the cheapest idea in the article. Take ten real questions from your comments or your WhatsApp and answer each in a thirty-second video, by name, with one person and one backdrop, in one afternoon. Ask before you use anyone's name, and if you run a clinic read the rules on patient information first.
  6. Agree the permissions in advance. Decide who can approve a reply on the day and which subjects are closed.
  7. Give people a reason to act now. An offer and a film together did more than either would have done alone.

For pet care brands the first point is most of the strategy. It matters nearly as much in healthcare, where the person choosing the hospital is often a relative of the patient.

If you would like help working out who your real buyer is and what would make them listen, the brief takes two minutes.

The next chapter in this series, and the last, is about a brand that put its customers' own work on its hoardings: Shot on iPhone.

Niraj Patadiya is a co-founder of Social Saga.

Frequently asked questions

What is The Man Your Man Could Smell Like?

It is a 2010 advertising campaign for Old Spice body wash, created by Wieden+Kennedy for Procter & Gamble. The first film, a single take starring Isaiah Mustafa, went online on 4 February 2010 and aired on television from 8 February, the day after the Super Bowl. It won the Film Grand Prix at Cannes that year.

Who is the actor in the Old Spice advert?

Isaiah Mustafa, an American actor and former professional American football player. He played the unnamed Old Spice man in the 2010 film and in the Response videos that followed, returned in 2015 in a series with the actor Terry Crews, and has played the character since, including in a 2025 Super Bowl commercial for another company.

Which agency made the Old Spice campaign?

Wieden+Kennedy, the Portland agency also known for Nike's Just Do It, which has handled Old Spice since 2006. Tom Kuntz directed the 2010 film. The Indian campaign of 2013, Smell Mantastic with Milind Soman, was also made by Wieden+Kennedy.

Did the campaign increase Old Spice sales?

Yes, with caveats. The agency says body wash sales were up 60% on the year by May 2010 and had doubled by July, and Nielsen figures showed a 107% rise in one month. A coupon promotion ran at the same time, and other data cited by Advertising Age showed sales roughly flat over the year to mid-June.

What was the Old Spice Response campaign?

In mid-July 2010 the Old Spice character answered comments and questions from people on Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and other sites with short personalised videos posted to YouTube. Wieden+Kennedy made 186 of them in two and a half days, and the campaign's awards entry counts more than 40 million views in a week. It is an early example of a brand replying to its audience in real time.

Was there an Indian version of the Old Spice campaign?

Yes. In October 2013 Old Spice launched its deodorant in India with a campaign called Smell Mantastic, starring Milind Soman as the Indian version of the character, with regional films themed on North, East, South and West. A second film followed in April 2014, which the trade press judged less successful.

← All chapters